In 2002 Catholic Charities USA and the Catholic Health Association sponsored
a study assessing the state of collaboration in Catholic ministries across the
United States. The study was conducted by Health Systems Research, Inc., and
was funded in part by a grant from SC Ministry Foundation. As part of the study,
researchers visited five sites (St. Petersburg/Tampa, FL; Cleveland; Wichita,
KS; Orange County, CA; and Albany, NY) to learn what makes for successful collaboration.
This is the second in a series of articles for Health
Progress highlighting the findings from this study, which will become available
later this year.
Collaboration among Catholic ministries in Cleveland centers in the organization
known as the Inter-Organizational Collaboration. The founding partners of this
group include:
- Catholic Charities Health and Human Services (CCHHS)
- Sisters of Charity of St. Augustine Health System
- University Hospitals Health System–The Sisters of Charity of St. Augustine
Health System (UHHS/CSAHS)–Cuyahoga, Inc. partnership hospitals
CCHHS is composed of several entities that provide a range of services to
people living in the diocese of Cleveland. CSAHS is the parent corporation for
the sponsored health and human service ministries of the Sisters of St. Augustine
and is composed of more than 20 health and human service ministries.
In 1999 CSAHS established two 50/50 nonprofit joint venture partnerships with
UHHS for its health care ministries in Ohio. One of these partnerships is UHHS/CSAHS–Cuyahoga
Inc., and includes, among other entities, St. John West Shore, St. Vincent Charity
Hospitals, and the Cuyahoga Physician Network, Inc., a network of physicians
who provide services in the Cleveland area.
Cleveland, located in Cuyahoga County, OH, has a population of approximately
500,000. In recent years, the population of the city has declined as families
have moved into the suburbs. Cleveland experienced some very difficult economic
times in the later years of the 20th century because of the decline of heavy
industry. However, the city has risen to the challenge of revitalizing the community
by creating new jobs and new enterprises, including a vibrant tourist industry.
The city continues to struggle, however, with typical urban problems related
to housing, jobs, and health and human services. Cuyahoga and contiguous suburban
and rural counties address a myriad of issues, including geographic access to
services.
Needed: A New Approach
The collaboration's founding partners were forced—by the need to address seemingly
overwhelming community health issues, to serve more people, and to maximize
available resources—to look for a new approach to planning, organizing, and
delivering health services in the greater Cleveland area. Community problems
were seen as complex and potentially overwhelming; therefore, a broad-based
strategy was needed to establish priorities and focus on developing comprehensive
services to address community needs.
CCHHS's leaders recognized that the services they offered were somewhat limited
and organizationally fragmented; they saw that a more seamless system of care,
responsive to the community, was needed. At the request of its president and
CEO, the organization's separate agencies began to work together more collaboratively,
recognizing that internal collaboration is a prerequisite to external collaboration.
As a result of this interagency cooperation, the organization was now in a
position to work with others who shared a similar mission and value system.
CSAHS and its sponsored hospitals, with their commitment to continue the healing
mission of Jesus, were natural and obvious collaboration partners. It was believed
that the coming together of these two systems would permit each to address the
community's needs in a comprehensive and holistic way that would not have been
possible if they had attempted to do so independently. The leadership from each
of these two systems saw the need for a structure in which issues could be "owned"
by the collective group rather than perceived as the specific responsibility
of an individual organization. The group could then address issues in a noncompetitive,
solution-oriented environment.
Collaboration
Over several years, representatives from the two systems and the sponsored
hospitals explored ways to work together to attain mutual benefits. However,
little materialized from these efforts because participants became bogged down
in institutional issues. But, beginning in 1996, the collaboration process dramatically
moved ahead as the result of two critical events.
A Three-Person Staff First, CCHHS, CSAHS, and CSAHS's partnership hospitals
in Cleveland agreed to jointly support the Inter-Organizational Development
Department, whose staff of three became responsible for the fostering of collaboration
efforts among the partners and within the community. Staff members owed allegiance
to the collaborative, rather than to a particular organization, and could therefore
act as boundary spanners among an array of actual and potential partners. These
three people recognized the different cultures, histories, and organizational
styles of each of the partners and were therefore able to facilitate understanding
and acceptance of those differences by the partners. Staff members were called
on now and again to "translate" for the partners, helping them to hear and truly
understand one another.
The Symposium The second critical event was the sponsorship by the
partners of a symposium called "Blazing Trails: Forming New Paths for Catholic
Charities and Catholic Healthcare." This symposium brought together, in a context
of collaboration, frontline health and social services workers and agency leaders,
all of whom were dedicated to the Catholic healing mission and the values articulated
in the New Covenant. The leadership of the sponsoring organizations used this
venue to share with their respective staffs their clear commitment to collaboration.
By focusing, in Blazing Trails, on the concrete needs of the community, small
group problem-solving sessions, and the spiritual connections between participants
in their overall work, the partners were able to push past their stereotypes
of each other and focus on developing ways to work collaboratively to get results.
These efforts, in turn, were facilitated by the full-time interorganizational
staff devoted to the strengthening of collaboration, one issue at a time. Blazing
Trails, which is now held semiannually, continues to be successful because of
its dynamic nature and the focus on "being present to the problem." As a Blazing
Trails collaborative group forms around an issue and develops an action plan
for it, that group is spun off and replaced at the next symposium with another
issue, which will then be addressed by yet another group of Blazing Trails participants.
Results
Among the successful initiatives sparked and facilitated by the collaborative
are the following.
Catholic Community Care Sixteen different organizations came together
to provide an integrated, vertical continuum of care, including home health
care for older adults. These organizations include Catholic acute care hospitals
with skilled nursing units, Catholic-based long-term care facilities, and the
Visiting Nurse Association, along with other community-based providers. This
continuum of care is accessed by the community through a centralized information
and referral service also developed by the collaborative.
Community Outreach The Wellness Project of St. John West Shore Hospital
and Catholic Charities provides a continuum of health and social services through
a single point of entry, the Catholic Information and Referral Services System.
A full-time case manager was recently hired to focus on the health service access
issues of the uninsured. This social worker is based in the hospital's Family
Medicine Center. The goal of this initiative is to reduce the inappropriate
use of emergency department services through prevention and early detection
and treatment, helping individuals and families who would have fallen through
the cracks of the system. Another aspect of this ministry is a program in which
nurse-parishioners volunteer to act as contact persons for their parishes for
information about available health and social services.
The Parish Connection Inspired by Bishop Anthony Pilla's pastoral Vibrant
Parish Life, the Parish Connection has been established to expand interorganizational
efforts to include parish pastoral ministry staff and volunteers in the work
of the collaborative. St. John West Shore Hospital and the Catholic Charities
Services Corporation are also partners in bringing services to the parishes;
in addition, they provide a parent-effectiveness training program to parishes
on the west side of Cleveland. Other special parish ministries include those
directed to diocesan members with disabilities, including persons with hearing
and vision impairments and mental retardation.
Migration and Refugee Program Although social services support had
been available to the refugee population through CCHHS's Migration and Refugee
Services, access to appropriate health services remained a problem. The collaborative
was able to remedy this by facilitating the partnership of the Cuyahoga Physician
Network, St. Vincent Charity and St. John West Shore Hospitals, and the Office
of Migration and Refugee Services in the provision of health care to the refugee
population.
Lorain County Collaboration St. John West Shore Hospital and Catholic
Charities have, under the auspices of the collaborative, developed several initiatives
in Lorain, the diocese's western-most county. These initiatives range from an
information and referral system to the direct delivery of health services in
senior centers and the county family center.
Lessons Learned
The director of the interorganizational team likens the process of collaboration
to "changing a tire on a moving vehicle." Although everyone has his or her own
individual organizational agenda and responsibilities to attend to, each deals
at the same time with the larger and cross-agency agenda of the collaborative,
all while managing this within the context of a dynamic community. This process
has taught all involved a great deal about how to make collaboration work.
Full-Time Staff Make a Difference A key lesson has been the importance
of staff who can focus full time on the vision and mission of the collaborative
and stay above the strategic plans of the individual partner organizations.
Their position of neutrality enables these people to keep the collaborative
vision in front of everyone, thereby preventing the groups involved from lapsing
into old categorical, hierarchical ways of doing business.
Create Opportunities to Get to Know One Another The partners see the
availability of opportunities to educate and understand one another as essential
to successful collaboration. Early on in the process, potential partners came
to the table often carrying uncharitable perspectives of each other and perhaps
assuming malevolent intentions on the part of other participants. People had
been burned in the past and were skeptical about working together. However,
as people came to know and trust each other through the taking of small, manageable
risks, mutual appreciation, respect, and trust gradually replaced skepticism.
Focus on All Organizational Levels The importance of simultaneously
working top-down and bottom-up with senior leadership, middle management, and
direct service providers is another important lesson. It was relatively easy
to get senior leaders to embrace collaboration, but much more difficult to obtain
commitment from junior and middle management. Not surprisingly, the partners
learned that it is the direct care providers who are the most supportive of
collaboration, indicating the usefulness of getting the opposite ends of the
organizational ladder together.
Recognize Different Organizational Approaches A major hurdle to collaboration
is the very different organizing principles used by the CSAHS and UHHS/CSAHS-Cuyahoga,
Inc., on one hand, versus those used by CCHHS, on the other. For example, Catholic
Charities is organized around parishes, social action, and service streams for
particular population groups such as children and families, older adults, emergency
assistance, or persons with disabilities. Hospitals, however, are organized
around individuals with health conditions and issues who come to a specific
place to obtain help in an acute care setting. The collaborative adapted to
this reality by making interorganizational development a priority in the life
of each of the collaborating organizations.
Collaborating around Funding Is Difficult but It Can Be Done The most
difficult challenge, however, in developing formal collaborative relationships
is that involving the management of categorical revenue streams, including Medicaid,
Medicare, commercial insurance, contracts, and fee-for-service arrangements
with city and county payers. Although the collaborative has become very creative
in paying for initiatives, it struggles with funders who encourage providers
to collaborate but who do not collaborate themselves in terms of commingling
their own funding streams. Despite this obstacle, the organization has been
able to fund an extensive array of collaborative efforts.
The Future
Given its early recognition of the importance of only taking on what is manageable
and has potential for success, the collaboration has grown incrementally. The
partners now believe that it is important to institutionalize the work of the
collaborative to ensure continued growth while sustaining current efforts. To
this end, the partners have recently announced the formation of the Caritas
Connection, a 50/50 joint venture corporation that will integrate many of the
Catholic-sponsored health and human services in the diocese. One of the initiatives
of the Caritas Connection will be the development of an integrated delivery
network to provide a seamless continuum of high-quality, low-cost, accessible
services for the low-income community.
The Caritas Connection's objectives are to:
- Ensure sustainability beyond the commitment of the present team
- Provide a vehicle for the development of fundable, reimbursable lines of
business
- Expand participation to include other Catholic ministries
- House more complex collaboration initiatives
- Leverage gifts among Catholic ministries to serve people
- Speak as one voice and influence public policy
- Derive mutual benefit