BY: WILLIAM J. COX
Mr. Cox is president and CEO, The Alliance of Catholic Health Care, Sacramento,
CA.
In recent years, thoughtful critics have questioned whether the institutional
Catholic health ministry can remain alive, vibrant, and formative, given the
context in which health care is delivered today. These critics cite a number
of factors threatening to overwhelm the distinctive identity and character of
Catholic hospitals. According to one such critic, these factors include: "1)
a depersonalized atmosphere, 2) where medicine is increasingly viewed as a business
3) [in] a time of powerful market and competitive pressures . . . 4) in a culture
that tries to transcend mortality, invests big time in sick care and medicalizes
more basic human problems, 5) at a time of the hospital's diminishing importance
and religious influence."1
The critics' most worrisome concern, however, is that Catholic health
care may be ill equipped to effectively address these largely external challenges
because the culture of Catholic health care itself is becoming dysfunctional.
That culture, which is anchored in the healing mission of Jesus, is Catholic
health care's raison d'etre — its meaning and purpose. Without
it, Catholic hospitals cannot continue to be efficacious church ministries,
much less sustain their identities in a rapidly changing external environment.
For nearly 200 years, the Catholic mission in U.S. health care was nurtured
by thousands of religious sisters who founded and operated Catholic hospitals
and brought to them "a spirit, a soul, an atmosphere and ideal of service
. . . which they create[d] and maintain[ed] and [gave] their lives' best
efforts to foster."2 Today, because of their declining numbers, those culture-bearers
are largely absent from the administration of Catholic hospitals and are increasingly
unavailable for its governance. Given this development, it is not clear how
the culture will be sustained and transmitted to the next generation of Catholic
hospital leaders.
Whether we are comfortable with the critics' observations or not, we cannot
dismiss them, because they come primarily from careful observers of the church,
people who value deeply the institutional healing ministry that has been one
of its most important ministries.
A Healing Response
In October 2002, the sponsors and senior executives of California Catholic health
care systems and hospitals and the state's Catholic bishops met in Palo
Alto, CA, to examine the major challenges facing the institutional health ministry
and to forge mutual commitments that would direct the church's energies
toward those challenges' successful resolution. Participants overwhelmingly
identified one particular opportunity for collective action: "Developing
and implementing a leadership program for formation with common foundations."
Before the meeting adjourned, participants appointed a work group made up of
volunteers from each of the health care systems and the California Catholic
Conference and charged it with developing the concept of a multisystem collaborative
ministry formation program. The work group was given a year to complete the
project. The Alliance of Catholic Health Care — an organization that represents
California's Catholic health care systems (comprising nearly 65 hospitals)
in Sacramento and Washington, DC — was asked to facilitate it.
During that year, the work group:
- Inventoried and identified the "best practices" of ministry leadership-formation
programs currently available from health systems, dioceses, educational institutions,
and CHA
- Regularly engaged and maintained the support of the major system/hospital
constituencies that would be required to make the effort a success
- Designed a format for, and identified the core elements and resources of,
a basic program in ministry formation
- Proposed a budget that would support the development and implementation
of a collaborative leadership-formation program
In October 2003, at a second gathering of California church and health ministry
leaders, the work group presented for review a draft business plan for developing
and funding a multisystem "Ministry Leadership Center." In February
2004, the CEOs of five systems located in the western United States — Catholic
Healthcare West, San Francisco; Daughters of Charity Health System, Los Altos
Hills, CA; Providence Health System, Seattle; Sisters of Charity of Leavenworth
Health System, Lenexa, KS; and St. Joseph Health System, Orange, CA — adopted
the business plan and agreed to fund the Ministry Leadership Center for three
years. The CEOs appointed the center's board of directors (see Box),
which then adopted the center's bylaws and initiated a national search
for a director. The director will be responsible for developing the center's
program and attracting competent staff and faculty. Actual ministry formation
is expected to begin in mid-2005.
Ministry Leadership Formation Defined
The center's business plan begins with a statement defining ministry leadership
formation as an extended, multifaceted process that enables leaders in Catholic
health care to understand and be empowered by Catholic health care's essential
mission — the continuation of the healing mission of Jesus; and to integrate
that understanding into the governance and operations of the healing ministries
for which they are responsible. Ministry Leadership Formation is a life-long
commitment that begins with:
- An understanding of the dynamic and transformative tradition of the Church
that forms the foundation of the healing ministry;
- A personal exploration of one's own "connectedness" to the
values and culture of the Catholic tradition in health care;
- An understanding of the distinctive integrated leadership competencies — intellectual,
affective and spiritual — required to lead a health care ministry in its
operations and governance.
The Catholic mission in health care is fundamental to the life of the church,
to its continued vitality, and to its mission in the world. The church's
presence in health care is especially important in a culture that is prone to
diminish human dignity by reducing human life and human relationships to the
status of a commodity. In such an environment, Catholic health care's transformative
presence is necessary to keep the human person at the center of medicine and
healing.
To date, Catholic health care has depended largely on the presence of women
religious to ensure that Catholic identity is perceptibly present and effectively
operative in the ministry. As the number of religious who are knowledgeable
about and available to work in health care operations and governance continues
to decline, it will not be possible to sustain the core identity of Catholic
health care unless the lay leaders who are primarily responsible for its operations — and
increasingly for its governance as well — participate in a robust formation
program in mission and ministry.
In the Catholic tradition, all baptized people — religious and lay — are
called, by virtue of baptism, to responsibility for ministry. This understanding
of who is responsible for ministry includes the broader notion of vocation that
has emerged in the Catholic tradition since Vatican Council II. All people,
whether they are Catholic or not, are invited to share in responsibility and
leadership for ministry. As Vatican Council II emphasized, all "are called
to be part of [the] catholic unity of the people of God, which is harbinger
of the universal peace it promotes. And there belong to it or are related to
it in various ways, the Catholic faithful as well as all who believe in Christ,
and indeed all women and men. For all are called to salvation by the grace of
God."3 All people of good faith, especially after formal instruction in
the fundamental values and moral priorities of the Catholic tradition, may thus
identify with and personally embrace an intentional commitment to the healing
mission of the church.
Catholic health care is authentic when its members provide care, develop healthier
communities, and act as advocates for others out of an intentional commitment
to the healing mission of the church. The central reality of that commitment
is a ministry that others, when they encounter it as community, experience as
a revelation of life's deepest truths — about human dignity, community,
success, power, growth, sacrifice, love, suffering, debility, and death. People
go forth from this experience more healed, more whole, more able to love and
hope.*
* John W. (Jack) Glaser, STD, vice president, theology and
ehtics, St. Joseph Health System, Orange, CA, developed this insight into
the nature of the ministry.
Understanding the deepest truths about the reality of human experience from
the perspective of the church, being empowered by that knowledge, and knowing
how to align the governance and operations of a complex health care organization
with its requirements — all this requires formal training and personal formation
in mission and ministry.
Such training is currently not available in a form compatible with the professional
and personal lives of most senior leaders in Catholic health care. And although
many of the existing mission programs for middle and upper-level managers convey
basic information about the church and the history of the sponsoring congregation
and also provide personal enrichment, they generally lack the intellectual and
spiritual rigor of ministry formation as outlined in the center's definition
cited above.
Two developments lend a sense of urgency to this matter. First, a new generation
of leaders is rapidly entering Catholic health care — a generation of leaders
well-trained in the business of health care but without formal training in mission.
Second, the sisters who have mentored earlier generations of lay leaders in
mission are increasingly unavailable for this task. When the sisters are gone,
who will be invested with the responsibility of both fostering the healing mission
of the church and mentoring future generations of leaders in that mission? How
will they be invested?4
Future Catholic health care organizations will not be able to claim the name
"Catholic" if an understanding of mission does not exist at nearly
every level of the organization; and mission cannot survive if Catholic health
care organizations do not find a way to renew it, maintain it, nourish it, support
it, and pass it on.5
The Centrality of Mission and Ministry
The central importance of mission and ministry is exemplified in the origins
of Catholic health care. The women religious who founded it were animated by
a commitment, rooted in a deep spirituality, to further the healing ministry
of Jesus. That conviction was the source of the creativity, ingenuity, persistence,
courage, and sacrifice that enabled them to serve the poor and the sick in the
face of what often appeared to be insurmountable obstacles, and to leave behind
them a rich legacy of institutions that today serve patients and communities
all across the United States. But their goal was not to build great institutions,
nor to earn a profit, nor to become shrewd businesswomen. They did these things
because they were vehicles for advancing the mission.
For the sisters, mission is not something extra, not an add-on, not an option.
Nor is it a matter of balance, spending half of one's time on mission,
the other half successfully providing health care. Mission is the source and
the motivation for how the sisters carry out their ministry — it is the reason
for their commitment and their success. In this regard, the sisters' most
important legacy is not the ministries they founded, for these have changed
innumerable times down through the years. Their most important legacy is something
that never changes, never becomes obsolete, and is always constant: an abiding
commitment to furthering the healing ministry of Jesus.
This experience from the world of faith-based health care has an ironic, but
powerful and instructive, parallel in the secular world of business. A six-year
research project at the Stanford University Graduate School of Business provides
compelling evidence that the most successful companies in the history of the
United States have had at their core and have consistently nourished a set of
fundamental beliefs and values beyond just making money.6 General Electric,
Hewlett-Packard, Sony, Ford, Procter & Gamble, and IBM are such companies.
Research shows that these companies don't merely declare their core beliefs;
they also take steps to make their beliefs pervasive throughout the organization
and transcend any individual leader. The researchers found that, compared to
a control set of comparable businesses, the companies they describe as "most
successful":
- More thoroughly inculcate in employees their core beliefs, creating a very
strong culture
- More carefully select and nurture senior management based on fit with the
core beliefs
- Attain more consistent alignment with the core beliefs in such aspects as
goals, strategy, tactics, and organizational design
The study emphasizes that the crucial variable distinguishing the "most
successful" companies from the control set is "how deeply the successful
organizations believe" in their core missions and "how consistently
they live, breathe, and express them in all that they do. Leaders and employees
of successful companies do not ask, 'What do we value?' They ask,
'What do we actually value to the core of our being.'"7
Leaders of the "most successful" companies are convinced — and
the data confirm their conviction — that consistently nurturing their core
beliefs, bringing them to life throughout their organizations, and aligning
them with key operational processes actually make a difference in their ability
to continuously adapt to and master changing markets.8
Like the sisters who founded Catholic health care, leaders of the "most
successful" companies do not consider mission an add-on or a question of
balance; they are convinced that it is their reason for being and the source
of their success.
Making ministry leadership formation available to Catholic health care executives
will produce such organizational benefits as a stronger culture, enhanced creativity
and innovation, and a greater ability to successfully negotiate rapidly evolving
markets and achieve positive market differentiation. But more importantly for
the church, the nation, and the people the ministry serves, it will enable Catholic
health care to sustain, well into the 21st century, a living experience of the
healing ministry of Jesus deep within its core.
Ministry Formation: The Goal
The Ministry Leadership Center's goal is to develop in each participating
health care system a critical mass of committed leaders who sense a personal
calling and are, in fact, called to a vocation in Catholic health care; who
are confident and competent, able to integrate an understanding of mission into
the operations and governance of the ministries for which they are responsible;
and who are able and willing to mentor the next generation of health ministry
leaders.
To achieve this goal, all current and aspiring leaders in the participating
Catholic health care systems will be expected to complete a rigorous three-year
program in spiritual, intellectual, and affective formation (see Box).
Each of the three years will have a set of common elements, such as the use
of adult learning principles, readings, guided reflection and ritual, didactic
input (theology/scripture, the Ethical and Religious Directives for Catholic
Health Care Services, and other church documents), online learning/interaction,
skills and tools needed for integrating content into operations and governance,
on-site mentoring in each system, and continuous evaluation with clear outcome
measures.
The Ministry Leadership Center estimates that some 500 executives in the five
participating systems will be eligible to participate in the program.
The formation program outlined above is demanding. Some people — perhaps
many people — will conclude that a three-year program in ministry formation
is just too much to ask of busy executives who are responsible for managing
large hospitals and health care systems. But the doubters need to ask themselves
a series of questions: "What is at stake if we don't do this? Are
the stakes worth the time, energy, and other resources required by this initiative?
Can effective formation in mission and ministry be achieved with less rigor?
Will Catholic health care be able to overcome the disorienting challenges described
at the beginning of this article if it does not have at its core a strong
culture that is imbued with a 'sense of sacramentality — God's
presence in all things — or of gratitude, of celebration, of shared joys
and burdens, of sensitivity to suffering and oppression, of concern for justice?'"9
The most successful companies in the United States prize their missions and
cultures; they believe those missions and cultures are the reason for their
success. Thus they require their busy executives to have a thorough understanding
of the missions and the necessity of aligning them with the companies'
operations. Some companies have even created internal "universities"
for the sole purpose of "mission formation." All of this is done to
advance important, but fundamentally secular, ends.
When Catholic health care leaders understand and have aligned their organizations
with the healing mission of Jesus, those organizations reflect in their policies,
culture, and behavior a deep belief that, in the words of Vatican Council II,
the "joy and hope, the grief and anguish of the women and men of our time,
especially those who are poor or afflicted in any way, are the joy and hope,
grief and anguish of the [ministers of Catholic health care] as well. Nothing
that is truly human fails to find an echo in their hearts."10
NOTES
- Richard A. McCormick, "The Catholic Hospital Today: Mission Impossible?"
Origins, March 16, 1995, pp. 648-653. See also Clarke E. Cochran, "Catholic
Health Care and the Challenge of Civil Society," presentation at the
Commonweal Colloquium on Catholics in the Public Square, Malibu, CA,
February 22-24, 2002; Charles Curran, "The Catholic Identity of Catholic
Institutions," unpublished presentation, Fordham University, Bronx, NY,
April 1996; and the extensive and insightful discussion of the significant
identity challenges confronting the Catholic Church's institutional ministries
of health care, social services, and higher education in Peter Steinfels,
A People Adrift: The Crisis of the Roman Catholic Church in America, Simon
& Schuster, New York City, 2003.
- Charles B. Moulinier, quoted in Sharon Pentland, "What's Past
Is Prologue," Health Progress, January-February 1995, p. 57. Fr.
Moulinier was CHA's first president.
- "Lumen Gentium," in Austin Flannery, ed., Vatican Council II:
The Conciliar and Post-Conciliar Documents, vol. 1, Costello Publishing,
Northport, NY, 1975, para. 13.
- See Margaret Steinfels, "The Catholic Intellectual Tradition: Colleges
and Universities," Origins, August 24, 1995, p. 171. In this article,
Steinfels asked the same question of the Association of Catholic Colleges
and Universities.
- Steinfels, p. 172.
- See James C. Collins and Jerry I. Porras, Built to Last: Successful Habits
of Visionary Companies, HarperBusiness, New York City, 2002. "Profitability,"
the authors write, "is a necessary condition for existence and a means
to important ends, but it is not the end in itself for many of the visionary
companies. Profit is like oxygen, food, water and blood for the body; they
are not the point of life, but without them there would be no life" (p.
56).
- Collins and Porras, p. 71.
- Assuming that $1 invested in the stock market in 1926 would have been worth
$415 in 1990, Collins and Porras calculate that if the dollar had been used
to buy stock in one of the "most successful" companies, it would
have brought $6,356 in 1990. Invested in one of the control companies, that
dollar would have brought only $995 (Collins and Porras, p. 4).
- Steinfels, p. 219.
- "Gaudium et Spes," in Flannery, para. 1.
The Three-Year Formation
Program
The Ministry Leadership Program will offer the following three-year formation
program for lay leaders:
Year One, Leadership Spirituality: "Who I am as ministry leader"
Content Areas for Year One:
- Vocation: Call and response
- Spirituality
- Deepening self-awareness
- Foundations of Catholic ministry
- Heritage of participants' systems
- Church's social teachings
- Leadership competencies
Components for Year One are an initial three-day, off-site retreat;
three two-day, off-site retreats; on-site mentor-guided exercises; collaboration
with and support from each participating system in completing the exercises;
journaling; and between-session assignments focused on application of lessons
learned.
Expected Outcomes for Year One are an affirmation of one's own
spirituality and the ability to articulate the value of being spiritually grounded,
an acknowledgement of the "fit" between one's own spirituality
and the traditions of the church and the founding religious community, and an
understanding of one's role as a ministry leader.
Year Two, Institutional Identity: "How I am present within this healing
ministry"
Content Areas for Year Two:
- Attention to body, mind, spirit
- Theology of healing
- Theology of suffering
- Health care as sacrament
- Professional relationships (ministry commitments)
- Clinical ethics
- Workplace dignity and justice
Components for Year Two are four two-day, off-site sessions (quarterly);
on-site mentor-guided exercises; collaboration with each participating system
in completing the exercises; journaling; and between-session assignments focused
on application of lessons learned.
Expected Outcomes for Year Two are an understanding of the role of spiritual
care and ethics in operations, an ability to articulate one's own call
to holistic care, a demonstrated ability to foster a healing community, an appreciation
of the value of end-of-life care in the Catholic tradition, and an ability to
assume responsibility for the Catholic ethical integrity of the ministry.
Year Three, Social Justice and Church Relationships: "Who we are in
our world"
Content Areas for Year Three:
- Organizational ethics
- Social teachings of the church
- Health care as a public ministry of the church
- The common good and preferential option for the poor
- Relationships with the institutional church
Components for Year Three are four two-day, off-site sessions (quarterly);
mentor-guided exercises; collaboration with each participating system in completing
the exercises; journaling; between-session assignments focused on the application
of lessons learned; and an optional immersion experience organized by each participating
system.
Expected Outcomes for Year Three: a personal commitment to fostering
the common good, a reaffirmation of one's personal vocational commitment
to Catholic health care as a social ministry, recognition of one's own
transformation as reflected in the ability and willingness to mentor others
in mission and ministry, and an understanding of and engagement in institutional
church relationships.
Work Group Participants
The work group developed the business plan for the Ministry Leadership Center;
it was disbanded with the appointment of the center's board of directors.
The work group's chair was Barbara Cox, RN, vice president, ministry leadership,
St. Joseph Health System, Orange, CA. The other members are:
Andrew Barna, administrative fellow, Daughters of Charity Health System,
Los Altos Hills, CA
David C. Blake, PhD, JD, vice president, mission and ethics/human resources,
Saint John's Health Center, Santa Monica, CA
Blair A. Contratto, CEO, Little Company of Mary Service Area, Torrance,
CA
Johnny Cox, RN, PhD, vice president, theology and ethics, St. Joseph
Health System, Orange, CA
William J. Cox, president and CEO, Alliance of Catholic Health Care,
Sacramento, CA
Lori Cappello Dangberg, vice president, Alliance of Catholic Health Care,
Sacramento, CA
Sr. Jane L. DeLisle, CSJ, council member, Sisters of St. Joseph, Orange,
CA
Edward E. Dolejsi, executive director, California Catholic Conference,
Sacramento, CA
Sr. Karin Dufault, SP, RN, PhD, vice president, mission leadership, Providence
Health System, Seattle
Fr. George Hazler, IV Dei, vice president, leadership formation, Daughters
of Charity Health System, Los Altos Hills, CA
Sr. Judith Jackson, SCL, vice president, mission and sponsorship, Sisters
of Charity of Leavenworth Health System, Lenexa, KS
Bernita McTernan, senior vice president, sponsorship/mission integration,
Catholic Healthcare West, San Francisco
Sr. Jeannine M. Percy, OSM, vice president, governance, Catholic Healthcare
West, Pasadena, CA
Sr. Suzanne Sassus, CSJ, senior vice president, sponsorship, St. Joseph
Health System, Orange, CA
Sr. Colleen Settles, OP, regional director, mission leadership, Providence
Health System, Southern California Region, Burbank, CA
Bishop John C. Wester, DD, auxiliary bishop, Archdiocese of San Francisco
The Ministry Leadership
Center's Board of Directors
Catholic Healthcare West, San Francisco
Rey Friel, vice president, mission integration
Sr. Brenda O'Keeffe, RSM, regional vice president, mission integration,
Mercy Medical Center, Redding, CA
Daughters of Charity Health System, Los Altos Hills, CA
Fr. George Hazler, IV Dei, vice president, leadership formation
Sr. Carol Padilla, DC, vice president, mission services
Providence Health System, Seattle
Sr. Karin Dufault, SP, RN, PhD, vice president, mission leadership
Greg Van Pelt, regional chief executive officer, Washington Region, Renton,
WA
Sisters of Charity of Leavenworth Health System, Lenexa, KS
Irma Napoli, vice president, human resources
David C. Blake, RN, JD, vice president, mission and ethics/human resources,
Saint John's Health Center, Santa Monica, CA
St. Joseph Health System, Orange, CA
Johnny Cox, RN, PhD, vice president, theology and ethics
Sr. Suzanne Sassus, CSJ, senior vice president, sponsorship
Alliance of Catholic Health Care
William J. Cox, RN, PhD, president and CEO, Sacramento, CA
Praise from Ministry Leaders
The Ministry Leadership Center has my full support. I am personally looking
forward to the opportunity of attending the sessions. I think one of the essential
competencies for any leader in Catholic health care is a clear understanding
of who we are as a ministry, what our roots are, and how that translates into
the decisions we make, our advocacy priorities, and our response to the call
to serve.
Lloyd Dean, President/CEO
Catholic Healthcare West
The Ministry Leadership Center presents an exciting opportunity to work with
our West Coast colleagues in Catholic health care and create experiences that
build on the best of what each of our systems has been doing and plans to do.
It will help us reach a level of excellence that none of us could attain on
our own. We see it as providential that it is coming together at a time when
ministry leadership formation has gained such strategic importance in our system
for management, governance, and sponsors.
John Koster, MD, President/CEO
Providence Health System
We celebrate the development of this collaborative ministry formation program.
It definitely will meet an identified need within our own health system. I have
every confidence that our leaders will welcome the launching of this program.
This initiative is essential for the integrated development of those who will
lead the Catholic health care ministry into the future.
William M. Murray, President
Sisters of Charity of Leavenworth Health System
The future of Catholic health care is directly dependent on the quality of
the women and men who will take on important leadership roles. My generation
was blessed to have members of our sponsoring communities as strong role models.
We need to invest now in leadership formation to make sure we have people who
are ready for tomorrow's challenges.
Bain Farris, President/CEO
Daughters of Charity Health System
This center is a great opportunity to collaborate on an essential aspect of
the health care ministry: leadership formation. Bringing our best thinking together
and producing an excellent program for ministry leaders will strengthen Catholic
health care far into the future.
Rich Statuto, President/CEO
St. Joseph Health System